Malignant lymphoma of the urinary bladder: a clinicopathological study of 11 cases
- 1Department of Histopathology and Morbid Anatomy, St Bartholomews and the Royal London School of Medicine and Dentistry, London E1 1BB, UK
- Dr Bates email:
- Accepted 29 November 1999
Aim—To report the clinical and histological features and outcome of primary and secondary malignant lymphomas of the urinary bladder.
Methods—Eleven cases of malignant lymphoma of the urinary bladder were obtained from the registry of cases at St Bartholomews and the Royal London Hospitals. The lymphomas were classified on the basis of their morphology and immunophenotype, and the clinical records were reviewed.
Results—There were six primary lymphomas: three extranodal marginal zone lymphomas of mucosa associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) type and three diffuse large B cell lymphomas. Of the five secondary cases, four were diffuse large B cell lymphomas, one secondary to a systemic follicular follicle centre lymphoma, and one nodular sclerosis Hodgkins disease. Four patients with secondary lymphoma for whom follow up was available had died of disease within 13 months of diagnosis. Primary lymphomas followed a more indolent course. In one case, there was evidence of transformation from low grade MALT-type to diffuse large B cell lymphoma. The most common presenting symptom was haematuria. Cystoscopic appearances were of solid, sometimes necrotic tumours resembling transitional cell carcinoma, and in one case the tumours were multiple. These cases represented 0.2% of all bladder neoplasms.
Conclusions—Diffuse large B cell lymphoma and MALT-type lymphoma are the most common primary malignant lymphomas of the bladder. Lymphoepithelial lesions in MALT-type lymphoma involve transitional epithelium, and their presence in high grade lymphoma suggests a primary origin owing to transformation of low grade MALT-type lymphoma. Primary and secondary diffuse large B cell lymphomas of the bladder are histologically similar, but the prognosis of the former is favourable.
Extranodal marginal zone lymphoma of mucosa associated lymphoid tissue type (MALT-type lymphoma) of the urinary bladder, first described in 1990, is the most common primary bladder lymphoma,1 and lesions that were previously described as reactive processes, “pseudolymphomas”, or low grade lymphomas of nodal type are now recognised as belonging to this group. The MALT concept provides a mechanism by which malignant lymphomas could develop in the bladder, as they do in other sites that normally possess no lymphoid tissue, after chronic inflammation.2 Primary high grade B cell lymphoma of the bladder is about as common as low grade disease, constituting 50% of the 72 primary lymphomas of the bladder reported up to 1997.1 Primary Hodgkin's lymphoma of the bladder is a rarity, with only two previous reported cases.3 Here, we review the clinical and histological findings in a series of 11 primary and secondary lymphomas of the bladder.
Cases of malignant lymphoma of the bladder were identified in the files of the institute of pathology at the Royal London Hospital and St Bartholomews Hospital. The histological appearances and clinical findings were reviewed, and the cases were classified according to the revised European-American lymphoma (REAL) classification.4 Clinical information was obtained from hospital records, surgical pathology reports, and necropsy reports from 1929 to 1998 inclusive. Lymphomas were accepted as primary if they presented with symptoms as a result of bladder disease, did not involve adjacent organs, and if there was no evidence of lymphoma elsewhere at the time of diagnosis. Low grade MALT-type lymphomas were stained immunohistochemically with antibodies directed against B cell markers (CD20 and CD43), CD21 to assess follicular architecture, and κ and λ light chains to demonstrate clonality. High grade primary and secondary lymphomas were stained for CD20, CD30, and CD3.
Eleven cases were identified, six of which were primary and five secondary. Brief clinical details are shown in tables 1 and 2. This represented 0.2% of all bladder neoplasms reported and 1.8% of secondary tumours of the bladder. All of the examples of primary lymphoma were surgical biopsy specimens. Four of the five secondary lymphomas were postmortem cases, and in no case was a systemic lymphoma initially diagnosed in the bladder.
The primary lymphomas comprised three low grade B cell lymphomas of MALT type and three diffuse large B cell lymphomas. The MALT-type lymphomas presented in elderly women and appeared cystoscopically as well defined masses, sometimes ulcerated, resembling transitional cell carcinoma, and in one case there were multiple nodules. The two patients in this group for whom follow up was available were alive at one and three years after diagnosis. Histologically, all of the cases of MALT-type lymphoma showed lymphoepithelial lesions in transitional epithelium (fig 1) and colonisation of reactive follicles by monocytoid B cells; two cases predating 1983 had been previously diagnosed as follicular lymphomas (fig 2). Plasmacytic differentiation was prominent in one of the three cases. All showed immunoglobulin light chain restriction.
Primary diffuse large B cell lymphomas typically presented in elderly patients with haematuria: one case from before the advent of immunohistochemistry was initially diagnosed as poorly differentiated carcinoma. Lymphoepithelial lesions and reactive follicles were present in conjunction with high grade lymphoma in one biopsy. One patient with diffuse large B cell lymphoma died of disease six months after presentation, but two others were alive after three years and 8 months and 16 years.
Secondary lymphomas included three diffuse large B cell lymphomas (fig 3), one diffuse large B cell lymphoma secondary to systemic follicular lymphoma, and one case of nodular sclerosis Hodgkin's disease. The presenting features were lymphadenopathy, lymphoedema, abdominal pain and masses, and rectovesical fistula. In four of the five cases, the diagnosis of bladder involvement was made at postmortem examination. The prognosis was poor: all patients for whom follow up was available were dead within 13 months of presentation.
Although lymphoid neoplasms arising in the bladder are rare, secondary involvement of the bladder by systemic lymphoma is relatively common, having been documented in 10–20% of all patients with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma at necropsy.5 The under-representation of secondary lymphomas in this series presumably indicates sampling bias: cystoscopic biopsies are unlikely to be taken from patients with systemic lymphomas who have symptoms referable to secondary involvement of the bladder, and at postmortem examination evidence of secondary lymphoma might not be sought in the bladder, unless a tumour mass that appears to merit histological investigation is noted. The incidence of primary lymphomas might have been increased because the study was carried out at a tertiary referral centre.
The concept of MALT lymphoma was proposed by Isaacson and Wright in 1983,6 and the first report of a case arising in the bladder was in 19907; however, the similarity of some bladder lymphomas to lymphoid lesions in the stomach had been noted even before MALT lymphoma was described.8 Since 1990, 14 other cases of primary MALT-type lymphoma of the bladder have been published.1,9–12 In our present study, none of the three patients with MALT-type lymphoma had a documented history of cystitis, but in no case had there been previous bladder biopsies, so the presence or absence of cystitis was difficult to ascertain. Simpson et al have found previously that 22% of primary lymphomas of the bladder were preceded by documented cystitis,13 and Osawa and colleagues14 found cystitis in only 20%, although in many cases cystitis might have gone undiagnosed. The presence of lymphoepithelial lesions and reactive lymphoid follicles in each of our cases supports the hypothesis that cystitis is a necessary precursor of MALT lymphoma, as experience with MALT lymphomas at other sites would suggest. Lymphoepithelial lesions are not a feature of the normal bladder,9 but are seen in MALT lymphoma in both transitional and glandular bladder epithelia.12 We did not find glandular metaplasia in our three cases of primary MALT-type lymphoma, and in each case lymphoepithelial lesions involved transitional epithelium, so we do not regard metaplasia as a prerequisite for formation of lymphoepithelial lesions, as has been suggested previously.1 Although only a small number of cases have been studied, the prognosis of MALT-type lymphoma confined to the bladder appears to be favourable,1 and so far only one patient with a MALT-type lymphoma of the bladder has been reported to have died of the disease.9 This suggests that MALT lymphomas of the bladder, in common with those at other sites, generally carry a good prognosis,15 and have little tendency to disseminate to non-MALT lymphoid organs. In the stomach, similar expression of lymphocyte homing receptors and vascular addressins in MALT of chronic inflammation and in MALT lymphomas suggests that MALT lymphomas tend to remain confined to their site of origin because mechanisms controlling B cell trafficking in normal MALT are also operative in MALT lymphoma.16 Analysis of integrin expression in acquired MALT and MALT lymphomas outside the gastrointestinal tract might help to explain the behaviour of these tumours.
High grade primary lymphomas of the bladder are almost always of diffuse large B cell type. Our finding of equal numbers of low and high grade primary lymphomas is in keeping with a recent extensive review of reported cases.1 There is only one report of a primary T cell lymphoma of the bladder.17 Older case reports of follicular and plasmacytic lymphomas are ambiguous because some of these cases would now be classified as MALT-type lymphomas, and it appears that primary low grade lymphomas of nodal type are rare in the bladder.18 Some reports do describe plasmacytoid lymphoma,18 but these might be MALT-type lymphomas with a high degree of plasmacytic differentiation. Isaacson19 considered it likely that primary high grade B cell extranodal lymphomas that arise from sites where low grade MALT-type lymphomas occur are themselves MALT lymphomas, and in addition to the case described here, in which there was evidence of a preexisting low grade MALT lymphoma, there are two other cases in the literature that suggest transformation from low grade to high grade MALT.20,21 However, it is not known what proportion of MALT lymphomas of the bladder undergo transformation to high grade lymphoma.
Although there is a relatively high incidence of bladder involvement in patients with systemic lymphoma, particularly in those dying of the disease, our experience indicates that secondary lymphoma in biopsy specimens is seldom likely to pose a problem for the surgical pathologist. Involvement of the bladder by secondary tumour appears to indicate a very poor prognosis, but it is exceptionally rare for disseminated lymphoma to present with bladder involvement. The prognosis of primary high grade lymphoma of the bladder is more favourable because, by definition, they are, at the time of diagnosis, confined to a single organ, and this difference justifies investigation to exclude systemic lymphoma if a high grade lymphoma is diagnosed in a biopsy.