Aims To create clinically relevant normative flow cytometry data for understudied benign lymph nodes and characterise outliers.
Methods Clinical, histological and flow cytometry data were collected and distributions summarised for 380 benign lymph node excisional biopsies. Outliers for kappa:lambda light chain ratio, CD10:CD19 coexpression, CD5:CD19 coexpression, CD4:CD8 ratios and CD7 loss were summarised for histological pattern, concomitant diseases and follow-up course.
Results We generated the largest data set of benign lymph node immunophenotypes by an order of magnitude. B and T cell antigen outliers often had background immunosuppression or inflammatory disease but did not subsequently develop lymphoma.
Conclusions Diagnostic immunophenotyping data from benign lymph nodes provide normative ranges for clinical use. Outliers raising suspicion for B or T cell lymphoma are not infrequent (26% of benign lymph nodes). Caution is indicated when interpreting outliers in the absence of excisional biopsy or clinical history, particularly in patients with concomitant immunosuppression or inflammatory disease.
- lymph node
- flow cytometry
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Flow cytometry immunophenotyping is a routine component of lymphoma diagnosis. Existing normative data for lymph node biopsies are based on small studies, many of which report a minority of flow gates used in routine diagnostics and were performed outside the clinical setting. Understanding the distribution of benign lymph node flow immunophenotypes is critical to prevent overdiagnosis of lymphoma, avoid unnecessary follow-up procedures and inform emerging research into automated gating.
We report the largest data set available on the distributions of clinically suspicious and ultimately benign lymph nodes, and detail immunophenotype outliers that raise suspicion for lymphoma.
The study was approved by the Stanford University Institutional Review Board. Data included 380 excised lymph nodes with paired flow cytometry and a benign final diagnosis. Samples were processed per routine institutional protocol with 30 000 events collected, and gating was performed for lymphocyte and large cell populations. The lymphocyte gate contains the CD45+ cluster with low forward scatter and low side scatter, and the large cell gate includes the CD45+ cluster with higher forward scatter and/or side scatter (online supplementary figure 1). Thresholds were set using isotype-matched fluorophore controls, and data were reported as % events above the threshold. Event data were analysed using RStudio (RStudio, available at http://www.rstudio.com) and reported for the following antigens/combinations: CD2, CD3, CD4, CD5, CD7, CD8, CD10, CD16, CD19, CD20, CD22, CD23, FMC7, kappa, lambda, CD56, CD57, CD10+/CD19+, CD5+/CD19+, CD3+/CD56+, CD3+/CD57+, CD3+/CD16+, CD3−/CD56+, CD3−/CD16+ and CD3−/CD57+. T cell antigen events normalised to CD3 levels are not reported for the large cell gate given known dim CD4 and CD56 expression on monocytes and aggregation of monocytes and T cells in the large cell gate.1 CD7 loss is estimated as percentage CD2+ minus CD7+ events and includes both T and natural killer (NK) cells, although T cells represent the majority of events. Immunophenotypic outliers were defined for antigen combinations (CD10/19+, CD5/19+, CD7 loss) per usual as >1.5 times the IQR above the third quartile, and for kappa:lambda light chain ratio as >3:1 or <1:1, and CD4:CD8 ratio as <1:1 or >10:1. For outliers, medical records were evaluated for subsequent lymphoma, lymphoproliferative disorders, prior malignancy, underlying immunosuppression (including solid/marrow transplant, chemotherapy, HIV, hypocomplementaemia, aplastic anaemia), autoimmune disease (including Graves’ disease, lupus erythematosus, Raynaud’s disease, psoriasis/arthritis, Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, autoimmune hepatitis, Sjogren’s syndrome) or inflammatory conditions (including sarcoidosis, Kawasaki’s disease, ulcerative colitis, atopy). Group differences were evaluated by Mann-Whitney-Wilcoxon statistical test.
Supplementary file 1
The cohort gender mix was 51.1% female and 48.9% male, and age distribution slightly skewed towards older patients (median=33.5 years old, range 8 months–82 years); nevertheless, paediatric patients are represented, with 129 patients under age 18. A median of 90% of events fall in the lymphocyte gate, and 5% in the large cell gate. In the lymphocyte gate, a median of 60% of events are CD3+ (T cells) and 32% are CD19+ (B cells) (figures 1–2, tables 1–2), and the opposite distribution of CD19+ (median=68%) and CD3+ (median=27%) events is present in the large cell gate, consistent with enrichment for larger germinal centre B cells (figure 1–2, tables 1–2). Clinical characteristics and median flow gate events were similar to previous studies of excised benign lymph nodes.2–9 Combined lymphocyte and large cell gate data are presented in online supplementary table 1.
Supplementary file 2
B lineage-related antigens (CD10+/CD19+, CD5+/CD19+, CD22, CD23, FMC-7) covary with percent CD19+ events, and kappa:lambda light chain ratios fall mostly within the normal range of 1:1 to 3:1 (table 1). Twenty-three kappa:lambda outliers (outside 1:1–3:1 ratio) were identified, 5 cases (1.3%) in the lymphocyte gate and 17 cases (4.4%) in the large cell gate (tables 3–4). These biopsies exhibited reactive follicular hyperplasia, with three cases notable for granulomatous histology. Outliers in the lymphocyte gate exhibited significantly increased CD10+/CD19+ events (outlier median=36%, non-outlier median=9.5%, p<0.01), and four of five patients were immunosuppressed (eg, status postorgan transplant) or had an inflammatory/autoimmune (eg, lupus erythematosus) condition. In contrast, outliers in the large cell gate did not have increased CD10+/CD19+ events, and 8 of 17 patients had history of immunosuppression or an inflammatory/autoimmune condition.
Median CD10+/CD19+ B cells events were low (9.8%) in the lymphocyte gate and 29.8% in the large cell gate, consistent with germinal centre enrichment, and the distribution is right-skewed with upper quartiles >22% and >55% in the lymphocyte and large cell gates, respectively (table 1). Outliers in the lymphocyte gate represent 5.7% (n=21) of cases and in the large cell gate 1.6% (n=5) of cases (tables 3–4). The top 10 CD10+/CD19+ outliers (five each for lymphocyte and large cell gates, one shared between groups) showed reactive follicular hyperplasia, with three cases additionally showing follicle lysis and two cases suggestive of HIV lymphadenitis. Eight of nine patients were either immunosuppressed or had an inflammatory/autoimmune condition.
Median CD5+/CD19+ B cell percentages were low (8.8%) in the lymphocyte gate and 11.8% in the large cell gate, with a right-skewed distribution showing an upper quartile >14.7% and >21.6% of events in the lymphocyte and large cells gate, respectively (table 1). Outliers in the lymphocyte and large cell gates represent 7.6% (n=28) and 4.7% (n=14) of cases, respectively (tables 3–4). The top 10 CD10+/CD19+ outliers (five each for lymphocyte and large cell gates, one shared between groups) showed mostly reactive follicular hyperplasia, and kappa:lambda light chain ratios were within normal range. CD5+/CD19+ outliers in the lymphocyte gate were significantly younger (outlier mean=13 years, non-outlier mean=33.9 years, p<0.05) and had increased CD5+/CD19+ events in the large cell gate (outlier median=40%, non-outlier median=11%, p<0.01). In contrast, outliers in the large cell gate were not significantly younger than the overall cohort (median age=31.4 years old) and did not have increased CD5+/CD19+ events in the lymphocyte gate (median CD5+/CD19+=31%). Four of nine outliers (44%) were immunosuppressed or had inflammatory/autoimmune diseases.
The distribution of FMC-7 and CD23 is broad in both lymphocyte and large cell gates (table 1), with FMC7 correlated to its epitope CD20 and CD22 slightly higher than CD19. CD19+ events are generally CD38+, more so in the large cell gate (p<0.01 vs lymphocyte gate). Percent CD19+/CD38+ events show a moderate positive correlation with CD10+ events (lymphocyte gate, r=0.29, n=353, p<0.001).
T lineage epitope (CD3, CD2, CD5 and CD7) distributions are reported for both the lymphocyte and large cell gates (figure 2, table 2), and the large cell gate is not further assessed due to non-specific binding (discussed above). Lymphocyte gated CD2, CD5 and CD7 track closely with CD3, and ratios for CD4:CD8 have a median of 3.5:1 as expected. CD4:CD8 outliers are frequent (8% of cases, n=32) (tables 3–4), and the top 10 CD4:CD8 outliers above 10:1 and below 1:1 reflect overall group demographics, and there is no increased CD7 loss or aberrant natural killer/T (NKT) phenotype (CD56/CD3 or CD57/CD3). Several distinct diagnoses are represented among <1:1 CD4:CD8 outliers, including histiocytic necrotising lymphadenitis (Kikuchi lymphadenitis), Castleman disease, granulomatous lymphadenitis and HIV lymphadenitis, whereas the >10:1 CD4:CD8 outlier group is enriched for immunocompromised/post-transplant status (70% of patients).
In terms of estimated CD7 loss, the cohort has a median of 2.7% CD2+/CD7− events in the lymphocyte gate, with the upper quartile >6.5 % CD2+/CD7− events (table 2). CD7 loss outliers (tables 3–4) represent 6.8% (n=19) of cases for the lymphocyte gate and the top 10 outliers did not contain aberrant CD4:CD8 ratios or aberrant NKT phenotype (CD56+CD3+ median=0.5%, CD57+CD3+ median=3%). CD7 loss outliers typically exhibited follicular hyperplasia (60% of cases).
Outliers mentioned above (kappa:lambda, CD10/CD19, CD5/CD19, CD4:CD8 or CD7 loss) represented 98 cases (26% of all cases, online supplementary figure 2). Among outlier cases, 76%, 20% and 4% of cases had one, two and three outliers, respectively. No patterns of covariance among outlier types were identified and the proportions of outlier types were 17% kappa:lambda, 19% CD10/CD19, 26% CD5/CD19, 26% CD4:CD10 and 6% CD7 loss. Outliers did not subsequently develop lymphoma, and group gender and age were similar to the overall cohort except for younger age in CD5+/CD19+ outliers.
Supplementary file 3
CD16+/CD3− NK cells, CD56+/CD3− NK cells, CD57+/CD3− NK cells, CD16+/CD3+ NKT cells, CD56+/CD3+ NKT cells and CD57+/CD3+ (cytotoxic and/or follicular helper) T cells showed low abundance (median=1%, table 2), and negligible events express mature markers (CD57+/CD3−, median 0% and CD16+/CD3−, median 0%), in line with previous data.10 11
We present the largest normative data set of common diagnostic flow immunophenotypic markers in benign lymph nodes and summarise clinical data in outlier groups.
Flow immunophenotypic assessment for B cell lymphoma relies predominantly on coexpression of CD5 or CD10 and light chain ratios. Previously reported mean/maxima for CD10 and CD5-positive B lymphocytes in benign lymph nodes were 16%/50% for CD10 and 15%/30% for CD5.12 13 A striking 5.1% and 6.9% of cases in the current study exceeded the previous maxima for CD10+ and CD5+CD19+, respectively. This is a potential pitfall since CD10 and CD5-positive B lymphocytes are conceptualised as minority populations in benign lymph nodes, and neoplasms of mature B cells are classified using aberrant CD10 and CD5 expression patterns.14 15 In the current study top outliers of CD10 and CD5 did not develop B cell lymphoma on subsequent (median ~4 year) follow-up.
Light chain restriction is another diagnostic clue for B cell lymphoma, although skewed light chain ratios have been reported in normal childhood tonsils, Castleman disease and reactive follicular hyperplasia.14 In the current study, aberrant kappa:lambda light chain ratios were present in 1.3% and 5.7% of cases in the lymphocyte and large cell gate, respectively, and were mostly attributed to germinal centre B cells, consistent with enrichment in the large cell gate and increased CD10+/CD19+ events. Previous reports of reactive benign lymph nodes showed ~1% cases with clonal light chain-restricted CD10+ germinal centre B cells representing at least 20% of total B cells.16 The current study similarly shows skewed kappa:lambda light chain ratios as a potential diagnostic pitfall occurring in a significant number of benign lymph nodes that do not subsequently develop lymphoma.
We assessed T cell immunophenotypic aberrancies that may be seen in T cell lymphoma. Loss and underexpression of CD7 is associated with roughly 54% of T cell lymphomas.17 In the current study, loss of CD7 on CD2+ events (T and NK cells) was usually low (2.7% of CD2+ events), but a surprising 39 cases (13.9% of cases) showed over 10% CD7 loss and 9 cases (3.2% of cases) had over 20% loss. NK cell epitopes (CD16+, CD56+, CD57+) were low with 0% and 1% medians, so CD7 loss was attributable to the T cell population. A previous study pooling non-T cell malignancy lymph nodes (benign, reactive, B cell lymphoma) showed similar low consistent loss of T cell epitopes, including occasional CD7 loss in greater than 20% of T cells.17 Our 10 cases with greatest estimated CD7 loss did not develop T cell lymphoma or T cell rich B lineage lymphomas (eg, Hodgkin lymphoma).
In the current study, 5.7% and 3% of CD4:CD8 ratios were above and below the normal 1:1–10:1 range.18 Aberrant CD7 or CD4:CD8 ratios of unknown significance have been reported in a variety of settings ranging from infection to transient effects of smoking,19 20 and in patients with HIV likely reflect absolute CD4 T cell deficiency. CD4:CD8 outliers within our cohort highlighted several benign entities, including histiocytic necrotising lymphadenitis (Kikuchi lymphadenitis), granulomatous lymphadenitis, HIV infection and dermatopathic lymphadenopathy.
Flow cytometry provides important ancillary information in the diagnosis of lymphoma, particularly when clinical or histology findings are limited, equivocal or mimic malignancy. It is critical to recognise borderline cases in order to avoid misdiagnosing lymphoma, and the current study estimates one-quarter of benign nodes exhibit outlier immunophenotypes suspicious for lymphoma. This study provides a comprehensive benign data set for manual and automated diagnosis of lymphoma.
Take home messages
Outlier flow immunophenotypes are seen in approximately 1/4 of benign lymph nodes.
Understanding of benign outliers is crucial to avoid overdiagnosis of lymphoma or unnecessary repeat studies.
Frequent outliers involving B cells include skewed kappa:lambda ratios, and increased percent CD5:CD19 or CD10:CD19 coexpression.
Frequent outliers involving T cells include <1:1 or >10:1 CD4:CD8 ratio or partial loss of CD7.
Clinical history often reveals an autoimmune, rheumatologic or immunodeficiency condition among outliers.
Handling editor Mary Frances McMullin.
Contributors GDS and DG planned the study. GDS performed data collection, software programming and analysis. GDS, DG, and SA conducted data interpretation, critical review and drafting of the manuscript.
Competing interests None declared.
Ethics approval Stanford University Institutional Review Board.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data sharing statement Raw flow event data will be made available by email request at the discretion of the corresponding author.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.