Background: The original role of the National Health Service breast screening programme (pathology) external quality assessment (EQA) scheme was educational; it aimed to raise standards, reinforce use of common terminology, and assess the consistency of pathology reporting of breast disease in the UK.
Aims/Methods: To examine the performance (scores) of pathologists participating in the scheme in recent years. The scheme has evolved to help identify poor performers, reliant upon setting an acceptable cutpoint. Therefore, the effects of different cutpoint strategies were evaluated and implications discussed.
Results/Conclusions: Pathologists who joined the scheme improved over time, particularly those who did less well initially. There was no obvious association between performance and the number of breast cancer cases reported each year. This is not unexpected because the EQA does not measure expertise, but was established to demonstrate a common level of performance (conformity to consensus) for routine cases, rather than the ability to diagnose unusual/difficult cases. A new method of establishing cutpoints using interquartile ranges is proposed. The findings also suggest that EQA can alter a pathologist’s practice: those who leave the scheme (for whatever reason) have, on average, marginally lower scores. Consequently, with the cutpoint methodology currently used (which is common to several EQA schemes) there is the potential for the cutpoint to drift upwards. In future, individuals previously deemed competent could subsequently be erroneously labelled as poor performers. Due consideration should be given to this issue with future development of schemes.
- EQA, external quality assessment
- NHSBSP, National Health Service breast screening programme
- RCPath, Royal College of Pathologists
- external quality assessment
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
The authors of this paper are members of the external quality assessment (EQA) scheme management group of the UK national coordinating committee for breast pathology, which is responsible for pathology quality assurance in the UK National Health Service breast screening programme and preparation of minimum dataset standards in breast cancer pathology for the Royal College of Pathologists. The committee acts as the steering committee for the UK national breast screening histopathology EQA scheme.
Membership of the UK national coordinating committee for breast pathology: Dr Al-Sam, Dr N Anderson, Dr L Bobrow, Dr I Buley, Mr D Coleman, Professor C E Connolly, Dr N S Dallimore, Professor I O Ellis, Dr S Hales, Professor A Hanby, Dr S Humphreys, Dr F Knox, Mrs S Kodikara, Professor S Lakhani, Dr J Lowe Dr J Macartney, Dr S Moss, Dr R Nash, Dr D Parham, Mrs J Patnick, Dr S E Pinder, Dr C M Quinn, Dr A J Robertson, Dr J Shrimankar, Professor R A Walker, Dr C A Wells, and Mr R Winder.