Table 1 Histopathological and immunohistochemical features of benign intraepidermal mimics of melanoma
Intraepidermal mimicHistopathological featuresImmunohistochemical features
Clear cell papulosis
  • Scattered clear cells along the basal layer of the epidermis

  • Lack of melanin, nesting, cytological atypia

  • AE1/AE3 cytokeratin (+), mCEA (+), EMA (+), GCDFP-15 (+)

  • S100 (−), HMB 45 (−), Mart 1/Melan A (−)

Pagetoid dyskeratosis
  • Scattered bland cells with pyknotic nuclei, perinuclear halo and pale cytoplasm in the upper layers of the epidermis

  • Absence of atypia, nesting

  • HMWCK (+)

  • mCEA (−), HMB 45 (−), S-100 (−), Mart 1/Melan A (−)

Toker cell hyperplasia
  • Bland cells with round nuclei and clear pale cytoplasm that predominate in the basal layer of the epidermis

  • Absence of pleomorphism and cytological atypia

  • EMA (+), LMWCK (+), CK 7 (+)

  • HMWCK (−), mCEA (−), HMB 45 (−), Mart 1/Melan A (−)

Granular cell tumour
  • Plump, spindle and epithelioid cells with abundant eosinophilic cytoplasm and inconspicuous bland nuclei

  • Cells mainly in the superficial dermis with varying degree of epidermal extension

  • S-100 (+), calretinin (+), inhibin (+), CD68 (+)

  • Mart 1/Melan A (−), HMB 45 (−)

Clonal seborrhoeic keratosis or melanoacanthoma
  • Well defined nests of large cells with distinct intercellular bridges or basaloid cells with small dark staining nuclei

  • Large, dendritic melanocytes scattered through the epidermis in the melanoacanthoma variant

  • Columns and sheets of basaloid to squamoid cells with intervening horn cysts and slender elongated rete ridges

  • Absence of cytological atypia

  • HMWCK (+) (fig 4B), P63 (+) (fig 4C)

  • S-100 (−) (fig 4D), HMB 45 (−), Mart 1/Melan A (−)

  • CK, cytokeratin; EMA, epithelial membrane antigen; GCDFP-15, gross cystic disease fluid protein-15; HMWCK, high molecular weight cytokeratin; LMWCK, low molecular weight cytokeratin; mCEA, monoclonal carcinoembryonic antigen.